Skip to main content

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

Vicar's Blog

A matter of choice?

29 November 2024

We live in polarised world. And even that statement has within it a problem of polarised opinions. If someone counters with “No we don’t!”, immediately they have proved that we do… (I will give you a few moments to run that through your head… ho hum … ok? Right, on we go).

It didn’t begin with social media such as Facebook, TikTok etc., but those platforms sure have revealed that everyone has an opinion and is prepared to tell you so. I know: I am one of them. I try to resist polarising the world, but mostly I fail.

Opinions. Mine vs. Yours. Right vs Wrong. Yes vs No. Poles apart, always. Today, as I write, the debate is about to begin regarding “Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill”, Kim Leadbeater’s Private Member’s Bill. You know all about it because it’s been very heavily covered in “the Media” (not just the Social kind). There will be debate and there will then be a vote, and a decision will be made. From an imponderable “life or death” question comes the requirement for a decision. And like so much in life, it depends.

How would you have voted? I absolutely don’t know. And so this is another of those moments when I am glad I am not a Member of Parliament. I have such conflicted attitudes towards this matter such that I am my own polar opposite. Inside me is turmoil and indecision. I can see the value and problems with both “sides” of the debate. This Bill demonstrates the complexity of moral philosophy. It reminds us just how important life is, how fragile it can be and how much we want to deny our own mortality.

The choice presented to the Commons is not actually about any single person’s life. Rather, it challenges those debating to make a choice that can either prolong suffering or end a life.

How would you have voted? In so many cases, Parliamentary business is relatively clear. Either vote for a policy that you endorse or vote against it because you don’t. Then sit back and watch how society is affected by your choices. However things develop you can simply remark, “I have my opinions”. The “Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill” doesn’t let you hide behind opinions. It doesn’t present you with polar opposites. It starkly throws up two choices which are both correct and also questionable. Both for very good reasons.

How would you have voted? When you work it out, please tell me. I could do with some help.

return to blog page