Books

Books

Books
Books

Books

Books

Books

Books
Books

Books

Books
Books
Books
Books
Books
Books
Books

Books
Books

Books
Books
Books

Books
Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books

Books
Books

Books

Books

Books
Books

Books

Books

Books

Beneficial or not?
What
It is known that the diocese is seeking to add Othery and Middlezoy to our benefice increasing the number of parishes, churches and schools by 50%. I see this as a local manifestation of a national problem with too little finance in the parishes and too much spent on diocesan overheads which absorbs both money and people
The church risks perpetuating a downward spiral in attendance and services and parish income by making bigger benefices with fewer clergy in parishes and dwindling attendance and engagement in the parishes.
At present our relatively new vicar (Simon) has established a pattern where each of the four present Athelney churches has a prayer morning each week. North Curry has two communion services most weeks and the other churches have frequent regular services. In comparison, one of our neighbours, The Benefice of Seven Sowers, four of the seven churches have only one or no communion services scheduled for May. At present, and fortunately, Revd Simon can draw on the assistance of Revd Martin and Ralph Roberts (our Reader) but this may be for a limited time.
There is evidence of success in Athelney both of growth in regular attendance in church and of community involvement. Also, regular contact is maintained with the two schools in our benefice. This momentum may be lost if the benefice is expanded.
Given the task of saving 1.5 full-time priest posts within the Sedgemoor Deanery one can see a desk-top logic in adding the Othery and Middlezoy parishes to the Athelney Benefice. If the proposal is enacted, then no doubt Revd Simon will do his very best to make it work. However, that could be to the detriment of more focussed work in the present Athelney benefice and may not meet the real needs in Othery and Middlezoy .
Why
I suspect that the proposal arises from the immediate problem of “balancing the books” within the diocese. The Bath & Wells Annual Report and Accounts for 2023 states that “ the operating deficit arose from the continued low level of parish share receipts.” However, the 2023 income from parish share and the diocesan stipends fund was £10.4m compared with the published cost of parish ministry of £8.9m. The operating deficit arises from the overhead cost of the diocese not necessarily a shortfall in parish share. Parish clergy could be afforded and are potentially available (according to Save the Parish there are more than 900 ordained people in the Church of England who are not in parish posts).
The Archdeacon may be bearing down with ideas for mergers, the true motivation for which is for the diocese’s rather than the parish’s benefit, to sell more property, or to reduce the number of clergy to reduce the costs of their stipends. In such circumstances, the PCC needs a clear head about its inherited responsibilities in a parish system which goes back to Saxon times and was further developed by the fourteenth century and should know and understand its responsibilities to future generations.
We need to establish how far the process has got.
We can resist the proposed change, but this must be done in a structured way. The potential penalty we face by objecting is that if/when there is a vacancy in the benefice it would not be filled. If Revd Simon were to leave Athelney the diocese could impose a lengthy or indefinite interregnum. I think we should resist the proposal and take the risk because in another ten years the Church may have a different policy. The signs of a change in direction are already emerging. A paper presented to General Synod in February 2025 says:
“In light of deteriorating financial sustainability in dioceses, the Diocesan Finances Review aimed to identify mechanisms to ease dioceses’ current financial stress in a way which helps to develop the Church’s longer-term missional and financial health, focusing on:
• The financial support of dioceses by the national Church
• The simplification of the Church’s financial systems primarily in respect of financial flows between dioceses and the National Church Institutions
The proposals recognise the immediate financial pressures on dioceses and the need to ease this stress, whilst enabling change within a longer-term mission, financial and people plan for sustainability and flourishing, as well as seeking to simplify complex, opaque and burdensome arrangements currently in place. The total package represents a cost of £220m time limited funding over 9 years, plus £30m in perpetuity. The Triennium Funding Working Group will therefore need to consider affordability and balance priorities alongside other funding requests in developing the spending plans recommendations for 2026-28.”
Source https://www.savetheparish.com/2025/03/18/diocesan-finances-review-update-2025/
What Can be Done
The joint issue of request for greater parish share and the inability of the diocese to pay for priests in parishes or benefices of manageable size should be thoroughly and prayerfully examined and debated by each PCC and, if thought fit, representations should be made to the Archdeacon, Chancellor, and Bishop.
Meanwhile organise locally. The vicar is a trustee, maybe ex-officio, of local organisations such as the local school and, some local facilities such as local charities. There are two points here: Firstly, try to engage these organisations to support our arguments for retaining our own clergy – or at least resisting further enlargement of our benefice. Secondly, in making our case point out that if our vicar is stretched over too many parishes, their contribution to these organisations will suffer from a lack of church input.
Everyone must insist on the absolute priority of the parish as the basic unit of the church. PCCs can easily become downtrodden with dwindling congregations and lack of volunteers. Suggestions of mergers or other forms of sharing resources can seem attractive. However, an incumbent living miles away may not be inclined to focus on our church if other churches in the benefice are faring better in attendance terms or have easier geography, parking, etc.
The PCC has unique statutory powers and responsibilities with which to determine the future of the parish and has the right (and sometimes the duty) to seek the support of the Charity Commission.
• If the diocese is hatching plans for our church’s future, an early indication that our parish will strongly resist attempts to dictate our parish’s future may be effective to deter the diocese from proceeding. The PCC’s need to know how far the proposals have got in this process:
• The diocese seeks the views of “interested parties” via Archdeacons and the Diocesan Mission and Pastoral Committee (DMPC)
• The diocese recommends proposals to the bishop (who can make a Bishop’s Mission Order or a Pastoral Order if all interested parties have agreed).
• We should see that any comments made by the PCC are passed on fairly to the bishop by the DMPC.
• Draft Scheme or Order published (anyone may object to Church Commissioners)
• If there are objections the Church Commissioners decide whether the Scheme or Order should go ahead.
• The bishop makes a Pastoral Order unless the Church Commissioners decide it should not be made.
• Objectors may seek Leave to Appeal against the Commissioners’ decision on a Pastoral Scheme or Pastoral Church Buildings Scheme.
• The Church Commissioners make a Scheme unless they decide it should not be made or there is a successful appeal against their decision that it should be made.
The functions of parochial church councils shall include raising of such matters as the PCC consider appropriate with the deanery or diocesan synod and we can both object to the proposal itself and also to the procedure if it has not been correctly followed.
Consequences
Some dioceses have gone much further than B&W has done yet in creating larger benefices or equivalent, with fewer priests. I am not aware of any reorganisation of this sort producing increases in church membership. The requests for parish share are becoming impossible to meet. The church risks perpetuating a downward spiral in attendance and services and parish income. But it doesn’t have to be this way. Local people must wake up and fight for what morally and legally belongs to their parish, not just meekly submit to proposals sent down to them by the Diocesan Board of Finance (DBF) or the Archdeacon. Use all the rights of appeal provided in church legislation. Appeals are heard by a national committee of the Church Commissioners, with a further right of appeal in some cases to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council where the case raises a point of law.
The links indicated in this article can be visited via the online version of the magazine (athelneybenefice.com/magazine) or here:
• Diocesan Annual report: https://issuu.com/bathwells/docs/03184_-_deanery_gatherings_issuu
• Save the Parish: https://www.savetheparish.com/
• Save the Parish at Synod: https://www.savetheparish.com/2025/03/18/diocesan-finances-review-update-2025/